Grounds for Divorce in California

What are the Legal Requirements and Grounds for a Divorce in California?

To file for divorce in California, certain basic legal requirements must be met, ensuring that the process adheres to state laws and guidelines.

Residency Requirement

At least one spouse must be a resident of California for six months and of the county where the filing is made for three months before filing the divorce petition.

Grounds for Divorce  

California is a no-fault divorce state, meaning that the spouse filing for divorce does not need to prove any wrongdoing on the part of the other spouse. According to California Family Code Section 2310, the grounds for divorce are typically "irreconcilable differences" or "incurable insanity."

Legal Process

The process begins with one spouse (the petitioner) filing a divorce petition with the court. The other spouse (the respondent) must be served with the divorce papers and given the opportunity to respond. If the couple agrees on the terms of the divorce, they can draft a written agreement. If not, the court will make decisions on their behalf during the proceedings.

Waiting Period

California law requires a minimum waiting period of six months from the date the respondent is served with papers before the divorce can be finalized. This period allows for the possibility of reconciliation or the completion of negotiations on divorce terms.

Fulfilling these basic requirements is the first step in the legal journey of divorce in California, setting the stage for the more detailed negotiations and decisions that will follow.

Grounds for Divorce in California: Explained

What are "irreconcilable differences" as grounds for divorce?

In California, "irreconcilable differences" serves as a broad legal ground for obtaining a no-fault divorce. This term encompasses any substantial reasons for which the spouses believe their marriage has broken down beyond repair, making it impossible for them to continue living together as a married couple. The law does not require the spouses to provide specific examples or evidence of these differences. Instead, it suffices for at least one spouse to declare that the marriage is irretrievably broken due to deep and unresolved conflicts.

Key Characteristics

• No Need for Fault: Unlike fault-based divorces, where one must prove wrongdoing by the other spouse (such as adultery or abandonment), citing irreconcilable differences eliminates the need for assigning blame. This approach aims to minimize the animosity and emotional stress often associated with divorce proceedings.
• Privacy and Discretion: By allowing couples to divorce without disclosing intimate details of their marital issues, the law protects their privacy and dignity, facilitating a more respectful and less contentious divorce process.
• Unilateral Declaration: A unique aspect of citing irreconcilable differences is that only one spouse needs to believe the marriage cannot be saved. Even if the other spouse disagrees and wishes to remain married, the court can still grant the divorce based on the petitioner's declaration of irreconcilable differences.

Legal Process

When filing for divorce on the grounds of irreconcilable differences in California, the process involves submitting a petition for dissolution of marriage to the court, indicating irreconcilable differences as the reason for the divorce. The legal system is designed to respect the decision to divorce without delving into the specifics of the couple's disagreements, focusing instead on resolving practical matters such as asset division, child custody, and support arrangements.

What is "incurable insanity" as a ground for divorce?

For this ground, there needs to be competent medical or psychiatric testimony that the spouse was at the time the petition was filed, and still is, lacking the legal capacity to make decisions. Cal.Fam.Code. § 2312.

In California, incurable insanity serves as a less commonly used ground for divorce, distinguished by its requirement for one spouse to prove that the other is suffering from a mental condition that is both severe and permanent. This ground is predicated on the idea that the affected spouse's mental state renders them incapable of participating in the marital relationship in a meaningful way, with no prospects for recovery. Unlike the more frequently cited irreconcilable differences, incurable insanity necessitates a substantial burden of proof, including medical or psychiatric evidence, to demonstrate the permanence and severity of the condition.

The legal framework for divorces based on incurable insanity is designed to address situations where a marriage cannot feasibly continue due to one partner's mental incapacity, which fundamentally alters the dynamics of marital obligations and support. The requirement for medical testimony ensures that the claim is substantiated by expert evaluations, reflecting the seriousness with which the law treats such allegations. This approach not only protects the interests of both spouses but also emphasizes the gravity of dissolving a marriage under these circumstances.

However, due to the stringent evidence requirements and the complexity of proving incurable insanity, divorces on this ground are relatively rare in California. The state's preference for no-fault grounds, such as irreconcilable differences, allows for a more straightforward and less invasive process, aligning with modern attitudes towards privacy and the minimization of conflict in divorce proceedings. Nonetheless, the provision for divorcing on the grounds of incurable insanity remains an important legal avenue for those rare cases where one spouse's mental condition makes continuing the marriage untenable, ensuring that the law can accommodate a wide range of familial and personal situations.

Examples of Irreconcilable Differences in California Divorce

When filing for divorce on the grounds of irreconcilable differences in California, couples may cite a variety of deep-seated disagreements or conflicts that indicate their marriage is beyond repair. Here are common examples presented in a numbered list:

1. Communication Breakdown: Persistent inability to communicate effectively, leading to unresolved disputes and emotional distance.
2. Financial Disagreements: Ongoing conflicts over financial issues, such as spending habits, debt, and financial planning, that strain the marriage.
3. Differing Life Goals: Fundamental disagreements about major life decisions, including career paths, residency, or whether to have children, that reveal incompatible visions for the future.
4. Loss of Trust: The breakdown of trust due to infidelity, dishonesty, or other forms of betrayal, which is often irreparable.
5. Incompatibility: General incompatibility stemming from differences in interests, personalities, or values that makes cohabitation difficult or unpleasant.
6. Lack of Intimacy: A significant decline in emotional or physical intimacy, leading to feelings of neglect, loneliness, or disconnect.

These examples reflect the broad spectrum of issues that can be categorized as irreconcilable differences. Importantly, in California, spouses do not need to provide specific evidence of these issues to file for divorce based on irreconcilable differences. This provision facilitates a more respectful and less adversarial divorce process, allowing the court to focus on equitable resolutions for both parties without delving into the personal conflicts that led to the dissolution of the marriage.

How can I get my marriage annulled instead?

To obtain a marriage annulment in California, you must prove that your marriage qualifies as either void or voidable under specific legal grounds set by the state. An annulment is a legal decree that a marriage was never valid from the beginning, as opposed to a divorce which ends a legally valid marriage. California law provides several grounds under which you can seek an annulment. These include:

• Incest: Marriages between close blood relatives are considered void from the start.
• Bigamy: A marriage is automatically void if one spouse is already married to someone else at the time of the marriage.
• Underage Marriage: If one or both spouses were under 18 and married without parental consent and a court order.
• Fraud: If the marriage was based on fraud or misrepresentation that goes to the essence of the marriage.
• Force: If one spouse was compelled to enter into the marriage under duress.
• Physical Incapacity: If one spouse is physically incapable of consummating the marriage, and this incapacity is incurable.
• Unsound Mind: If either spouse was of unsound mind or unable to understand the nature of the marriage contract and the obligations it entails.

If my state has both fault and no-fault divorce, does it matter if I apply for a divorce on fault-based grounds?

California is a no-fault state. However, in states where both fault-based and no-fault grounds for divorce are recognized (read more about the pros and cons of each), there are several key differences between the two approaches that can impact the divorce process and its outcomes.

Do you need a divorce lawyer? What are your options?

The decision whether to file on grounds of abandonment is difficult in an already painful time. Consulting a lawyer that can help guide you through this process is often a good idea.

Hiring a lawyer is not your only path to getting legal guidance for your situation. Several lawyers and law firms have worked with Gavel to produce “legal apps” that can help you with this process:

• For those in California, Colorado, New York, Texas, and Utah; we have an app that guides you through divorce end to end
• For others in the US, this app can get you started
• Lastly, we have an app for Canadians

‍